I see it differently fellers. Keegan and Richard both had a 9-11 record in the regular season. So, in determining the playoff match ups we must look at the head to head record. They faced each other only twice in the regular season (weeks 5 and 14) which they split. Richard, however, had the most points in total and therefore gains the higher cede (is that a word?).
So, I think that all was correctly carried out. I was third overall and faced Richard who was effectively sixth overall. Mike was second overall and face Keegan who was effectively 7th overall.
Whew.
G